By Chris SwanMANAGING DIRECTOR | PRACTICE LEADERThe labor market runs hot, businesses scramble to keep their best leaders, and the counteroffer comes back into fashion. When a high performer resigns, the reflex is to match or beat the outside offer on the spot.
It is flattering to be wanted that badly. It is also, more often than not, a decision people regret.
If you are holding a counteroffer, slow down before you accept. These four questions will tell you far more than the number on the table.
A counteroffer almost always addresses money, because money is the easiest thing to change quickly. But money is rarely why people leave.
If you began looking because of the role, the culture, the manager, or a ceiling on your growth, a raise does not touch any of that. Be honest about what actually drove you to the market, then ask whether the counteroffer fixes it or just papers over it.
There are real gains to staying: familiarity, security, and more money without the risk of a new environment. Name them clearly so you are deciding on facts, not fear of change.
But weigh them against a hard reality. Research has found that roughly 80% of senior executives lose trust in an employee who accepts a counteroffer, and 71% question that person's loyalty afterward.
The raise is real. So is the quiet reassessment happening above you.
The cost of a counteroffer is mostly invisible at first. Your standing internally can quietly shift, because leadership now knows you were prepared to leave.
Your reputation with the firm that made you an offer, and the network around it, can take a hit too. This matters because the same research shows about three quarters of people who accept a counteroffer leave within three years anyway, often on worse terms than if they had gone the first time.
Set the counteroffer against what you were about to gain. When people who decline the counter and move on are surveyed, roughly 75% secure more money in the new role and about 61% say the job is better overall.
That does not mean staying is always wrong, but it does mean the counteroffer needs to clear a higher bar than a raise. It has to credibly fix the reasons you looked.
The counteroffer is designed to solve the company's problem, which is losing you, quickly. Your job is to work out whether it solves yours.
If the real issue was compensation and the counter genuinely resets it, staying can be right. If the issue was anything deeper, a bigger paycheck rarely holds for long.
If you are weighing an offer either way, it helps to know how to negotiate it well, and if a difficult manager is part of the picture, our piece on why people leave their boss is worth reading before you decide.
Sometimes, but the odds are sobering. Research has found that a large majority of people who accept a counteroffer leave within a few years anyway, and that senior leaders often lose trust in an employee once they know that person was ready to go.
That is the question worth sitting with. If the value was there all along, it is fair to ask why it took a resignation to surface it, and whether the underlying reasons you looked will actually change.
Keep reading
Chris Swan on a pattern he has watched for two decades: the leaders who run multidisciplinary teams best are rarely the ones who know the most. They are the ones who stop pretending to.
Read More →If work is following you home in the form of worry, the problem is often not the job, it is the manager. How to tell the difference, whether to try to fix it, and when the right move is to leave.
Read More →Millions of jobs sit open while employers struggle to fill them. The forces behind the skilled labor gap, from a retiring generation to a demographic shortfall behind it, and what organizations can do to compete.
Read More →Experience the Difference
We have the world’s best industry experts, proprietary innovation, and an unparalleled global network. Let’s find the leader your organization needs.